Overthinking and the Cartesian questions
In my opinion there is no such thing as overthinking. I think those who accuse others of overthinking a problem are they, themselves, seriously underthinking. Do they have all of the data that you have? Are they privy to the nuances of your problem? Are they ready to hand you a solution on a silver platter or are they content with mocking you? Cartesian questions may be your way to end your current “overthinking” state.
Consider: When your mind is stuck in a loop, or you are considering all possible outcomes or solutions to your current problem, and haven’t found any good ones yet – what are you actually doing? You are looking for more data. If you need an answer, and you haven’t found it yet, you have some choices: 1) Give up, ignore the problem, and get on with your life; 2) Ruminate on the problem endlessly, succeeding only in stressing yourself out; 3) Find the missing data which will lead to better understanding or solutions to your problem.
Clearly, if you do not have all of the data needed to solve or understand your problem you have not been overthinking, you have been underthinking. This goes back to the old saying, “Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” This is not an actual clinical definition, but it is common sense. I think we all know it, but don’t heed the implications often enough.
If someone tells you that you are overthinking, regardless of their knowledge of your problem, or why they feel qualified to make that remark, you can take it as a signal to stop thinking for a moment, and write out your problem and what you have considered so far. Look for an escape from the “box” that you have gotten yourself trapped in. I find using the four, Cartesian questions to be helpful in a lot of situations.
There are four questions. Write the first one down and then write every answer you can think of, before going on to the next question. You may not have sure answers to all the questions, but do the best you can and your insight will be clearer by the time you have gotten through the fourth one.
What will happen if I do? What will happen if I don’t? What won’t happen if I do? What won’t happen if I don’t?
If your problem involves more than a simple choice between two options, you may have to work at each part of the problem with a set of these four questions until you have narrowed your thoughts down to the answer you were looking for all along. If you still can’t find a satisfying answer, maybe you aren’t asking the right questions. It may be time to get outside help. I know a lot of people are averse to seeing a therapist, but the number one thing therapists are good for (if they are good therapists) is helping you find new questions to ask yourself.
Here is a bonus problem solver for the easier, either/or questions you sometimes ask yourself – like, “What should I for lunch today, eat at my desk while I keep working, or take my sandwich to the park?”: Flip a coin! The trick is not to force yourself to take the option presented by the head or tail of the coin, but to monitor how you feel when the coin is revealed.



Comments